Fancy face cream, elaborate floral arrangements, breakfast in bed: The traditional list of go-to Mother’s Day gifts is seemingly endless. (An adorable coupon book filled with vouchers for hugs and dish-washing never failed to be a hit in our household.) However, even shopping pros like us admit that buying something for the mom who already has everything can prove a daunting task. With that in mind, we circulated a top-secret (kidding) questionnaire to the mamas of R29 to ask them the very question you yourself may be hesitant to pose to your own madre: What’s at the top of your Mother’s Day wish list? Ahead, peruse and shop their honest and thoughtful responses below.